Click Here to Join for FREE!  Login 
A Family Outdoor Learning Center

  Search Site
 You Are Here: ..:: Discussions ::..
Your Own Lake Lot  
20 Acres Hunting Land
Lake County, Minnesota
Up North
20 Acres Hunting Land
Full details
Brainerd Lakes Area Lakeshore
Emily, Minnesota
Ross Lake
Brainerd Lakes Area Lakeshore
Full details

Outdoor Adventure Audio CD - Trout Whisperer
Outdoor Adventure CD
Trout Whisperer

Listen to Sample

Buy Now
 


About Us  

Departments  

Resources  

Outdoor News  

Minnesota | Camping Forum | Fishing Forum | Hunting Forum | Outdoor Photography forum | Nature Forum

Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Michigan Camping forums - Hiking forums - Fishing forums - Hunting forums - Nature forums - Outdoor Photography forum - Join the fun!

Forget Barack Obama and John McCain -Trout Whisperer for President

camping forum | fishing forum | hiking forum | hunting forum | nature photography forum

A great, friendly, place to find tips, get questions answered and to post your thoughts. Give it a try and post a message.

Feel free to post messages on any subject. But be nice, no profanity, no name calling, no commercial posts.

Members -  be sure to check for new pics in the Photo Gallery.

You just need to Register for free and Login to post a message in the forums.

Outdoor Recreation Forum Moderator: 
Buck Anderson

 2008 Presidential Election Poll  
Who will you vote for in the 2008 Presidential Election?



Submit Survey  View Results

Subject: Plan to Shoot Wild Cats Sparks Reactions
Prev Next
Please login to post a reply. Not a member? Register now.

Author Messages
FishFinderUser is Offline
JustNorth All-Star
JustNorth All-Star
Posts:85
Send Private Message
3/30/2005 10:42 PM  
From an excerpt from By Robert Imrie
Associated Press — March 30, 2005

"WAUSAU, Wis. — A La Crosse, Wis., firefighter who as a youngster cared for a cat named Fluffy ignited a firestorm by proposing that free-roaming wild cats be declared an unprotected species in Wisconsin — just like a skunk. People could shoot them, drown them or kill them by any means without being charged with a crime.

Cat lovers reacted angrily as they conjured up images of a cat-hunting season. Some suggested Mark Smith, a father and husband, become a targeted species with an open season on callous firefighters.

"I personally picked up the phone at work on four threat calls," Smith said about the first days after his idea hit the news.

Smith, 48, a hunter and trapper, said he expected flak for advocating getting bird-killing cats no one wants out of the wild. But he was unprepared for the anger and dismay at what he considers a reasonable solution for a wildlife and environmental problem created by irresponsible cat owners.

"Maybe I am emotionally inept, but I don't understand the reaction these people are having," he said. "I guess they need to be put in a room with a bunch of these cats."

At least two upper Midwestern states, South Dakota and Minnesota, have allowed wild cats — nicknamed "ditch cougars" in Minnesota — to be shot for decades, just like skunks or gophers.

Critics of Smith's idea, calling it inhumane and silly, organized Wisconsin Cat-Action Team and developed a Web site — dontshootthecat.com. They are mobilizing cat lovers to attend upcoming meetings for an advisory vote on the plan.

"You don't take on cats. It is one of the most popular companion animals in the world," said Ted O'Donnell of Madison, founder of Cat-Action and owner of five rescued cats. "Why would you propose an idea that would treat that relationship so callously?"

Trap wild cats in problem areas, perhaps pay a $15 bounty, spay or neuter them, release them and the issue goes away because they are not reproducing so rapidly, he said."

What is your opinion?

HOGEYEUser is Offline
JustNorth Pro
JustNorth Pro
Posts:424

Send Private Message
3/31/2005 12:16 PM  
I don't believe that cats have a special protection in either state as it is, so I don't know what all of the fuss is about.

Nathan "HogEye" Kestner
JustNorth Outdoors Columnist
JustNorth Outdoors Pro Staff
Team JustNorth Core Team
scumfrogUser is Offline
JustNorth All-Star
JustNorth All-Star
Posts:123
Send Private Message
3/31/2005 1:47 PM  
Hello, spay or neutering them is not going to stop them from killing the birds just from having babies. And who's going to pay the vet that does it, US the tax payer. I have 4 cats so I guess that makes me a cat lover. But my cats don't go outside. If a stray cat is killing birds and causing problems then it should be taken care of humanly.

Is shooting them right? I would say no. I think trapping and having them put to sleep would be better then shooting them.

By the way I also have 3 dogs. So don't jump all over my cats.

CPRproUser is Offline
JustNorth Veteran
JustNorth Veteran
Posts:63
Send Private Message
3/01/2006 4:41 PM  
 wrong or not - I have shot cats in the woods!
Please login to post a reply. Not a member? Register now.
Forums > Outdoors Recreation Forums > Conservation Issues > Plan to Shoot Wild Cats Sparks Reactions



ActiveForums 3.7

Message attachments are for uploading a picture to your post. Allowed file types are jpg and gif. Max file size is 600 kb. For help see Frequently Asked Questions.

Bookmark this page, tell your friends, and visit us often. We enjoy your company!

Recent Topics  
Coming to Minn. by ctperk :: Camping - Hiking - Nature - Travel Forum
Replies :: 1
Needing scraps or parts you don't use by Beth :: Hunting Forum
Replies :: 0
Been Awhile by CrappieMagnet :: Ask Randy Johnson
Replies :: 4
Milwaukee Fishing Lake Michigan Salmon Reports 8/7/2008 by Jim Blue Max Charters :: Fishing forum
Replies :: 0
how to start a log pile by trout whisperer :: Ask Trout Whisperer - Pro Guide and Columnist
Replies :: 3
Aitkin County is updating its Controversial Shoreland Ordinance by justnorth :: Conservation Issues
Replies :: 1
Candidate fame spreading... by lablover47 :: The Back Room
Replies :: 4
Thank you to TW and the Gang by RandyMan :: Fishing forum
Replies :: 8
Campaign proclamation!! by lablover47 :: The Back Room
Replies :: 3
Hey fishermen, I wanna know... by lablover47 :: The Back Room
Replies :: 10

Recent Posts  

Click to view JNO departments
Outdoors LibraryFishingHuntingCamping and HikingSnow SportsWomen OutdoorsWhat's New at JustNorth Outdoors

Your Friends Aren't JNOs?
Invite them to Join JustNorth Today

About This Site  Site Map  Contact Us  Sample Articles  Join JustNorth  Link to Us  Tell a Friend

Minnesota | Camping Forums | Fishing Forums | Hunting Forums | Nature Forums | Outdoor Photography Forums 

Fully Searchable Forums For Outdoor Enthusiasts

JustNorth Outdoors hunting and fishing discussion forums - Have questions or comments about creating outdoors videos, outdoors photography, hunting, fishing, ice fishing, camping, skiing and snow sports, conservation issues, gear, or politics? Participate in the forums...

Copyright 2008 Jive Media Group LLC. All Rights Reserved.  | Terms Of Use | Privacy Statement | Advertise With Us
Page generated in 0.2964038 seconds.  reduce website downtime | powered byVisit Jive Media Group LLC